SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth
Collective Negotiation Agreement (CNA)
The Collective Negotiation Agreement, referred to as CNA or Agreement, the 1987 Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines, and Executive Order No. 180 dated June 1, 1987, recognize and guarantee, among others, the right of government employees to self-organization and collective negotiations. CBSUA, cognizant of the provisions of the 1987 Philippine Constitution and Executive Order No. 180 series of 1987, adheres to its implementation, thus recognizes and supports the right of faculty members to self-organization and collective negotiation.
Appendix A: GRIEVANCE MACHINERY
In order to address the grievance of the rank-and-file, the University and the Association shall adopt the Guidelines on the Adjustment of Complaints and Grievances in the Public Sector as provided for in Memorandum Circular No. 45, s. of 1989. The settlement of complaints and grievances shall adopt the following:
I. Rationale
Sec. 35 of PD 807 provides that “All employees shall have the right to present their complaints and grievances to management and have them adjudicated as expeditiously as possible in the best interest of the agency, the government as a whole, and the employee concerned.” Thus, the agency is mandated to promulgate rules and regulations governing expeditious, fair, and equitable adjustment of employee complaints or grievances in accordance with the policies enunciated by the CSC. It is the main objective of this guideline to provide grievance machinery whereby employee complaints and grievances can be heard and adjusted expeditiously at the lowest possible level of the organization.
II. Objective
- To help promote management-employee peace and better relations thereby fostering harmony in public service and partnership for sustainable development and productivity.
- To settle the dispute at the lowest possible level of the unit of the University.
- To settle disputes in accordance with any contract or Agreement signed between the management and the CNA Negotiating entities within the terms of the agreement.
- To prevent discontentment and disenchantment between and among officials and employees.
- To enable the Union to participate in resolving the complaints as well as grievances of employees.
- Allow the parties to appeal from the results of the grievance negotiation step by step until a final, binding, and executory decision is reached.
III. Scope and Coverage of the Grievance Machinery
This Grievance Machinery (GM) applies to all discontentment or dissatisfaction that arises from day-to-day working relationships between and among officials and employees, and in the case of the recognized or accredited Union, between the Union and the management. GM does not apply to cases of dissatisfaction with official actions finally taken by the Agency or in disciplinary cases.
Classification of Complaints and Grievances may include:
- Between and among individual employees and supervisor/management:
- Policies, practices, and procedures on economic issues such as financial and other terms and conditions of employment fixed by law.
- Non-economic issues:
- Policies, practices, and procedures that affect employees from recruitment to promotion, detail, transfer, retirement, termination, lay-offs, etc.
- Physical Working Conditions.
- Interpersonal and inter-organizational relationships and linkages.
- Arbitrary exercise of discretion and/or management prerogative.
- Between management and the Recognized Negotiating Unit (ASSOCIATION):
- Economic issues and other economic packages fixed by law.
- Political Issues:
- Recognition of the Negotiating Unit/Entities.
- Association security and check-off.
- Violation of provisions and/or policies on Self-Organization.
- Violation of the voluntary agreement reached between management and the ASSOCIATION.
- Any and all matters giving rise to employee dissatisfaction.
IV. Definition of Terms
For purposes of uniform understanding, the terms used in this guideline are defined in their operational definition as follows:
- Complaint – means an employee’s expressed (written or spoken) feelings of dissatisfaction with some aspects of his working conditions, relationships, or status that are outside his control.
- Grievance – refers to a complaint in writing that has, in the first instance and the employee’s opinion, been ignored, overridden, or dropped without due consideration.
- Grievance Procedure – refers to the method of determining and finding the best way to remedy the specific cause or causes of the complaint or grievance.
- Modes of Settling Employee-Management Disputes:
- Conciliation – a process whereby a third party (conciliator) brings the parties together and encourages them to discuss their differences and assist them in developing their own proposed solutions.
- Mediation – a process whereby a third party (mediator) is more active in assisting the parties reach out with acceptable solutions to the problem/s and help the disputing parties develop or come to acceptable solutions to the problem.
- Arbitration – a process whereby a third party (individual arbitrator), a board of arbitrators, or an arbitration court not acting as a court, is empowered to make a decision that disposes of the dispute.
- Voluntary – a method of settling dispute/s by submitting the controversy before an arbitrator or panel of arbitrators chosen by both parties. The voluntary arbitrators shall render a decision after a proper hearing of the issues. The decision of the arbitrator shall be binding on the contending parties.
- Compulsory – a method resorted to when the dispute has become hardened and irreconcilable and remains unresolved after exhausting all the available remedies under existing laws and procedures.
V. The Grievance Procedure
A. For an Association member who would file his complaints and grievances through his initiative:
- Oral Discussion: A complainant shall present orally his complaints to his supervisor who shall, within three (3) working days from the date of presentation, inform the employee orally of his decision.
- Grievance in Writing: If the employee is not satisfied with the oral decision, he may submit his grievance in writing within five (5) working days from receipt of the oral decision of his immediate supervisor to the higher supervisor. The grievance shall pass through his immediate supervisor, who shall forward the grievance with his comments within five (5) working days to the next higher supervisor, as the case may be, who shall within five (5) working days from receipt thereof inform the employee in writing through the immediate supervisor of his decision; PROVIDED, HOWEVER that where the object of the grievance is the immediate supervisor, the complainant may bring the grievance to the next higher supervisor who shall take proper action within five (5) working days from the receipt of the complaint.
B. If the complainant is not satisfied with the decision of the higher supervisor, he may appeal his grievance to the Grievance Committee within five (5) working days from receipt of the decision, through the higher supervisor. The higher supervisor shall make the necessary comments and forward the grievance within five (5) working days to the Grievance Committee who shall, within ten (10) working days from the receipt of the grievance, conduct an investigation and hearing. The Grievance Committee shall furnish the complainant with a copy of its decision within five (5) working days after the investigation and hearing, through the supervisor and immediate supervisor; PROVIDED, HOWEVER, that where the object of the complaint is the higher supervisor, the complainant may bring his case directly to the Grievance Committee.
C. If the complainant is not satisfied with the decision of the Grievance Committee, he may elevate his case to top management through the president of the union or its authorized representative within five (5) working days from receipt of the decision. The Grievance Committee shall furnish management comments on the grievance within five (5) working days. Management shall decide within ten (10) working days after receipt of the grievance; PROVIDED, HOWEVER, that where the object of the complaint is top management, either or both of the parties may request conciliation/mediation services.
D. If the complainant is not satisfied with the decision of top management, either or both parties may request conciliation or mediation services from the Civil Service Commission which shall render the same within ten (10) days.
E. The aggrieved parties may file a petition for reconsideration with the Commission within five (5) working days from receipt thereof.
F. The Commission’s decision is final, binding, and executory unless an appeal from said decision is brought to the proper courts.
G. Appeal to the courts by either party shall be in accordance with the Rules of Court.
VI. Composition of the Grievance Committee
The Grievance Committee shall be composed of the following for Association Members:
- One (1) member of the top management or representatives to act as Chairman;
- Two (2) higher supervisors chosen by both the higher supervisors or association;
- Two (2) Association Officers or members chosen from among themselves;
- An alternate or alternates chosen by the association members with the consent and approval of the management.
VII. Form and Content of the Written Grievance
The complainant shall fill up the grievance form which shall provide the following information:
- Name of the complainant
- Position Title
- Designation (if any)
- Present Section or Division Assignment
- Immediate Supervisor
- Present Department or Unit Assignment
- Higher Supervisor
- Nature of Grievance in Brief
- Adjustment Desired
- Signature of Employee
- Signature of Union Official/representative (if applicable)
- Date of Filing from the lowest level in the agency
VIII. Implementation of Decision
Unless appealed, the decision of the concerned authorities shall take effect immediately and/or upon receipt of the decisions of all the parties involved.
IX. The Responsibilities of Personnel Officer / Records Keeper of the Recognized Negotiating Unit
All records involving complaints and grievances shall be kept by the Personnel Officer of the Agency and the record keeper of the recognized negotiating unit.